PNN - We Cover the Nonprofit World
Philanthropy News Network
Make us your home page!
Front Page
News Summary
Corporate Giving
Education
Foundations
Fundraising
Giving
Innovations
Law, Taxes Money
People
Technology
Volunteers

About PNN
Contact Us
Sponsors
Links

Conferences
Nonprofit Jobs
Online Classes

Free Tech Report
Free Email Alert

Join Us
email us
June 26, 2000
education

Gifts to public schools growing, but are they effective?

The growing awareness about the plight of public schools has caught the eye of philanthropists, who last year gave a total $27.5 billion to educational causes for everything from physical improvements to scholastic achievement.

What's more, these donors are giving large gifts to individual public schools, a rare event in past years but something that's becoming increasingly common now. Even though this new source of revenue is better than no help at all, critics say these large donations aren't enough to change things in the nation's public school systems, the Christian Science Monitor reports.

"The myth is that if you give enough money to a poor school system it will improve. It's just not that simple," Jeanne Allen, president of the Center for Education Reform, told the newspaper.

The Thomas B. Fordham Foundation has released a report titled "Can Philanthropy Fix Our Schools?" It examines 18 sites that received money from a 1993 grant of $500 million from the Annenberg Foundation and finds the money that was spent made "small footprints" on the schools, but hasn't close to reforming these systems, the newspaper reports.

Another concern is that donors making large grants may exercise control over school systems, and that charitable programs can distract teachers and administrators who are already overburdened. Defenders of these gifts say neither concern is realistic, and that any philanthropic gift is minuscule when compared to overall spending by school systems.

Regardless of the criticism, it appears big gifts to public schools are a strong future trend. Other recent large gifts to schools include

  • $359 million from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to improve public schools nationwide;
  • $95 million from the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation for community after-school initiatives;
  • $81 million from Pew Charitable Trusts to support standards-based reform;
  • and $71 million from the Milken Family Foundation for the National Educator Awards Program.

    Full text of the article is currently found at:
    http://www.csmonitor.com/durable/2000/
    06/20/fp16s1-csm.shtml



  • Mail this article to a friend What do you think?
    Reply to this article, click here.

    Back to the top
    Free e-mail alert
    RELEVANT ARTICLES:
    Report: Annenberg's $500 million schools-improvement effort missed goals
    Gondas give $1.5 million for UCLA's elementary school
    Online degrees offered at dizzying pace
    RELEVANT LINKS:
    Center for Education Reform
    Thomas B. Fordham Foundation
    "Can Philanthropy Fix Our Schools?"
    Annenberg Foundation
    Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation
    Charles Stewart Mott Foundation
    Pew Charitable Trusts
    Milken Family Foundation
    National Educator Awards Program
    IN THIS SECTION
    $2.25B more to wire schools, libraries
    Online degrees offered at dizzying pace
    Child suicide rates motivate nonprofits to act
    AmeriCorps to help bridge digital divide
    Philander Smith College gets $8M Methodist gift
    UCLA's elementary school gets $1.5M gift
    School violence reporting system raises concerns
    Technology offers new way to recruit teachers
    MORE NEWS:
    For more news, please visit our News Summary.